I Made a Concrete Countertop and Didn’t Expect the Surface to Feel Like This

Concrete countertops are often described as smooth, modern, and refined. I expected the surface to feel finished once the concrete dried. It didn’t. Even after curing, the countertop felt rough and slightly chalky, more like a workshop surface than a kitchen one.

What I didn’t expect was how much the feel of the surface would change only after the finishing steps were complete.

How the Countertop Was Made

This was not a poured concrete slab. I used a thin concrete skim coat applied directly over an existing countertop, built up in layers and left to cure fully between applications. The goal was a modern concrete look without the cost or weight of a full pour.

Visually, the surface looked solid once dry. By touch, it was clear the concrete was still very much unfinished.

What the Surface Felt Like at First

After the concrete dried, the countertop looked solid but felt raw. Running a hand across it revealed fine grit and subtle unevenness. The edges felt sharper than expected, and the surface picked up dust easily.

From a distance, it looked acceptable. Up close and by touch, it did not feel like something meant for daily use.

What Sanding Actually Changed

Sanding helped, but not in the way I expected. Coarser grits knocked down ridges and high spots, while finer grits softened transitions and edges. The surface became more uniform visually, but the overall feel remained dry and textured.

Sanding shaped the countertop. It did not finish it.

At this stage, the surface still absorbed moisture instantly and felt closer to raw cement than a kitchen surface.

Why Dry Concrete Doesn’t Feel Finished

Concrete does not level or polish itself as it cures. As moisture evaporates, pores remain open at the surface, creating texture and absorbency. Even after sanding, those pores are still present.

Until they are addressed, concrete looks done but feels unfinished.

When the Surface Finally Changed

The biggest shift happened after the 511 Impregnator Sealer was applied. The surface darkened slightly and stopped feeling dusty, but it was still textured. It felt protected, not finished.

The real change came after the Safecoat Acrylacq topcoat went on. The countertop became smoother to the touch, the fine grit disappeared, and the surface finally felt intentional. It no longer grabbed at cloths or fingertips. The finish felt consistent from edge to edge.

This was the feel I expected much earlier in the process.

What Surprised Me Most

I assumed smoothness came from the concrete itself. It doesn’t. The concrete defines the shape and character, but the finishing layers define how the surface feels in everyday use.

Until those layers are applied, concrete behaves like a raw material, not a finished countertop.

What I Would Do Differently

I would plan the project around the finishing stage, not the concrete application. Expecting a smooth surface too early makes the process feel disappointing when nothing has gone wrong.

Once I treated sanding, sealing, and topcoating as the real transformation, the results made sense.

Concrete countertops do not feel finished when they dry. The surface only becomes smooth and usable after sanding and finishing layers are applied, which is where the real transformation happens.

The post I Made a Concrete Countertop and Didn’t Expect the Surface to Feel Like This appeared first on Homedit.